Cait Martin, a powerhouse 34-year-old vocalist from Atlanta, brought her undeniable talent from the high seas to The Voice stage—and the coaches couldn’t get enough.

Taking a bold risk, Cait delivered a slowed-down, emotionally charged rendition of Harry Styles’ “As It Was.” Within seconds, Kelly Clarkson was sold, slamming her button in record time.

As Cait soaked in the moment, her biggest cheerleader—her mom—was already on a mission. Chanting “Kelly! Kelly! Kelly!” from the audience, she made her coaching preference crystal clear.

Never one to waste an opportunity, Kelly jumped in first, raving about Cait’s “effortless” high notes, stunning vibrato, and impeccable control. And it worked—Cait took her mom’s advice and made the winning choice: she’s officially Team Kelly!

Watch the jaw-dropping performance that had Kelly pressing her button in seconds!