He’s built a legacy on eye rolls and brutal honesty, but Simon Cowell just showed us his softer side—and we’re not okay.

Known for his icy glare and no-nonsense critiques, the America’s Got Talent judge was left in tears after one emotional performance by father of six, Michael Ketterer.

Michael, who earned Simon’s golden buzzer earlier in the season, revealed a tragic backstory—his wife nearly died during pregnancy, and doctors warned it could happen again. The couple then chose adoption, welcoming six children into their lives, including three siblings they took in together.

During the live show, Michael performed James Bay’s “Us,” and even the famously stoic Simon couldn’t hold it together. Choking up, he called Michael “really, really special,” praising not just his talent, but his story and heart.

Yes, Simon Cowell cried—and we’re still not over it.

Watch the performance and grab those tissues—you’re gonna need them!